The Pulse Report

What Does It Mean to Be Ahead?

We have a fairly settled idea of what it means for a country to be ahead.

Wealth. Infrastructure. Universities. Capital. Technology. Strong institutions.

Those things matter enormously. But they also describe advantage in the world we already have.

So what happens when a technology like artificial intelligence begins changing that world, but doesn’t arrive everywhere under the same conditions?

In the United States, much of the conversation about artificial intelligence is shaped by questions about what it could disrupt: jobs, professions, privacy, intellectual property, and businesses built around expertise. Increasingly, people are asking what AI might do to the way we learn and think.

Those aren’t abstract concerns. People have built careers, companies, institutions, and ways of learning around capabilities AI may change.

The questions can look very different elsewhere. What if specialized expertise is difficult to reach? What if access to a good teacher, physician, financial adviser, or programmer is limited?

The question may be less about what AI could take away and more about what it could make possible.

We are already seeing some evidence of that difference. A 2025 University of Melbourne and KPMG study surveyed more than 48,000 people in 47 countries and found significant differences in trust, use, and attitudes toward AI across countries and economies.

Gallup found another interesting difference. Among people aware of AI, 68 percent in Nigeria expect it mostly to help their country. In the United States, 36 percent do. But the same survey found enormous variation elsewhere: 93 percent in China, 91 percent in Vietnam, 35 percent in Egypt and 34 percent in Bangladesh.

The differences don’t fall neatly along geographic lines. But something gets lost when we talk about AI as though everyone is encountering the same thing: where you start may change what the technology means.

The Same Technology, Different Starting Points

Technology arrives inside what already exists: infrastructure, institutions, laws, businesses, habits, assumptions, capabilities, and unmet needs.

For someone whose livelihood or expertise is embedded in an established system, AI may represent disruption. What happens to knowledge that took decades to acquire? What happens to professions when some of their expertise becomes widely available? What happens to companies built around capabilities that were once scarce?

Someone without ready access to those capabilities may encounter exactly the same technology differently.

For one, the question may be:

What could AI take from me?

For someone else:

What could AI give me that I’ve never had?

Neither response is necessarily more right than the other. They begin from different places.

We have seen versions of this before. Mobile phones spread rapidly across Africa without countries first reproducing the extensive fixed-line systems built elsewhere. Mobile money created another unusual leap. The World Bank reports that about 40 percent of adults in Sub-Saharan Africa now have a mobile money account, while also cautioning that adoption of more sophisticated technologies, including AI, remains much slower.

The absence of infrastructure wasn’t an advantage. It created real disadvantages.

But when another path became possible, people didn’t necessarily have to travel through every stage that had come before it.

Different Clocks

Alvin and Heidi Toffler spent years examining what happens when parts of society change at different rates. They called it desynchronization.

Technology can accelerate quickly. Markets respond. Businesses adapt. Government, education, laws, infrastructure, professions, and culture have their own clocks.

But those different clocks don’t operate only within societies. Countries enter periods of change carrying very different layers of what came before. Some have enormous systems already in place. Others have gaps that new technologies may allow them to move around. Still others have spent years preparing their people and institutions for continuous technological change.

Estonia is an interesting example of the last one.

Nearly 30 years ago, Estonia began its Tiger Leap, bringing computers and internet access into schools as part of a much larger effort to build a digital society. Now it is trying another leap. Its national AI Leap began with upper-secondary students and teachers and is expanding. The emphasis isn’t simply on giving students access to AI. Estonia’s education minister describes its approach as “teachers first, technology second.”

Estonia isn’t an example of leapfrogging in the same sense as mobile phones or mobile money in parts of Africa. What is interesting is the continuity. For nearly three decades, it has repeatedly tried to bring people, education, and institutions along as technology changes.

Existing capability and adaptability are not the same thing.

What Does Preparation Look Like?

But Estonia doesn’t give us an answer either. It raises another question. What does it actually mean to prepare people for a technology that is still changing?

One response to AI in education is to teach young people how to work with it. Another is to protect parts of childhood and learning from it until foundational capabilities have developed.

Those approaches may look contradictory, but they can begin with the same concern: How do children learn to think in a world where machines can increasingly do some of the thinking for them?

Estonia initially focused its AI Leap on older students and teachers. Its program combines access with teacher training, learning applications, and digital literacy.

Preparation isn’t the same as speed. We may want young people to learn to do things with AI, and we may want them to learn other things before they rely on it. We don’t yet know where that line should be.

Which brings us back to what it means to be ahead. Is it the one with the most advanced technology? The one adopting it fastest? The one protecting certain human capabilities longest? The one with fewer legacy systems to change? Or the one whose institutions can change direction as evidence accumulates?

What Becomes an Advantage?

In Powershift, the Tofflers’ thinking about the changing relationships among knowledge, wealth, and power came together. AI puts those relationships under pressure again.

Much of today’s discussion understandably focuses on who controls the models, data, computing infrastructure, and capital.

But control isn’t the only part of the power equation. Who can use AI to access something that previously required money, geography, education, institutional standing, or permission?

What happens when people who already have those things and people who don’t begin using the same technology?

As humans, machines, businesses, markets, and institutions become increasingly connected, they aren’t all entering that system from the same place. Connection doesn’t erase where any of them started. They bring different histories, infrastructure, needs, capabilities, and experience with change into the network.

We tend to think about the AI divide in terms of who has access and who doesn’t. Who has the technology, compute, capital, and talent? Those remain critical questions.

But access doesn’t tell us what the technology means once it arrives.

For some, AI may threaten something valuable that already exists. For others, it may provide access to something previously out of reach.

We have long measured advantage by what societies have accumulated: infrastructure, capital, education, technology, institutions. Those things still matter.

But periods of rapid change may expose something those measures don’t capture very well: what happens when the world those advantages were built for begins to change.

And the closer we look at those differences, the less obvious it becomes what being “ahead” actually means.

Deborah Westphal is the author of The Pulse of Tomorrow (opens in a new tab) and CEO of the Karen Toffler Charitable Trust. More about Deborah →

Continue reading

All Pulse Reports →