Four years ago, while traveling through the Philippines, I was impressed by people’s ingenuity in repairing, modifying, or repurposing almost anything. Motorcycles, cars, and an extraordinary variety of vehicles were kept running with whatever materials and parts were available. People repurposed old military metal trackway panels, originally designed to help vehicles cross muddy ground, into fencing and other useful structures. The streets were filled with vehicles of every imaginable configuration, including colorful jeepneys, adapted from surplus World War II military jeeps and still a familiar form of public transportation in the Philippines. There was little of the uniformity we take for granted in the United States.
What stayed with me wasn’t the age of the equipment, but the knowledge, creativity, and independence of the people working with it. They understood enough about how things worked to diagnose problems, improvise solutions, and adapt what they had to what they needed.
Back home, the contrast is hard to miss. When something goes wrong with a car, computer, phone, or HVAC system, diagnosing the problem increasingly requires specialized equipment, proprietary software, or access to information the owner doesn’t have. Modern systems have brought extraordinary advances in safety, efficiency, convenience, and capability. They’ve also fundamentally changed our relationship with the things we depend upon.
The Changing Meaning of Ownership
For much of the industrial era, purchasing a product generally meant acquiring considerable control over its use, maintenance, and repair. Owners could use independent technicians, buy replacement parts, or try repairs themselves.
Owning something no longer necessarily means controlling everything required to keep it working.
A modern automobile may depend on proprietary software, remote updates, specialized diagnostic tools, and manufacturer-controlled components. A smartphone depends on operating systems, applications, networks, and cloud services. Even household appliances and agricultural equipment can require electronic authorization or specialized tools for certain repairs.
Subscription services and maintenance agreements add another dimension. We may own the physical equipment while depending on someone else to keep it functioning. These arrangements can improve reliability, provide access to expertise, and make increasingly sophisticated systems easier to maintain. They also change who has the authority to make decisions about those systems.
The person who purchases a product may no longer possess the practical ability to determine how it is maintained, modified, or repaired. Decisions once made by owners and independent repairers may now depend on manufacturers and service providers.
The right to repair is one visible expression of this shift. Beneath the arguments over parts, tools, and software lies a larger question: who controls the knowledge needed to keep modern society functioning.
When Knowledge Becomes a Source of Power
Specialization is hardly new. Modern civilization depends on people possessing different kinds of expertise. No individual understands everything involved in manufacturing an aircraft, operating an electrical grid, or developing a pharmaceutical treatment. These systems are possible not through universal understanding, but through the relationships that connect specialized knowledge.
Knowledge is becoming more specialized, but proprietary systems, commercial agreements, digital platforms, and institutional boundaries increasingly determine who can access it.
There is a difference between a system being difficult to understand and the knowledge needed to understand it being inaccessible.
Knowledge provides more than expertise. It lets people question, challenge, adapt, and act independently. When a farmer needs manufacturer authorization to complete certain repairs, or a local technician can diagnose a problem but lacks access to the software needed to fix it, the consequences go beyond inconvenience. Knowing how to solve a problem and having the authority to solve it are becoming two different things.
The July 2026 settlement agreement between the Federal Trade Commission and Deere illustrates this shifting balance of power. At the center of the dispute was access to the diagnostic tools, software, and information farmers and independent technicians need to repair equipment.
These changes are occurring at different speeds. A software update can alter what a product does overnight, while laws governing ownership and repair may take years to catch up. Manufacturers can change service agreements, discontinue support, or restrict access to information long after a product has been purchased.
The consequences extend past individual owners. A disruption in one part of a digital network can ripple through organizations and communities far removed from its source. The systems we rely on are increasingly interconnected, yet the relationships that support them are often hard to see until something stops working.
Consider what happens when one of those relationships breaks down. Equipment may be mechanically sound but unusable because a software service is unavailable, or a community may possess the expertise to restore essential infrastructure but lack access to the information or components needed to do so.
Efficiency and resilience are not the same. As we build increasingly capable and interconnected systems, are we also preserving the knowledge, authority, and flexibility necessary to respond when circumstances change?
The Next Layer of Complexity
AI is beginning to change who can access and apply specialized knowledge.
It can put sophisticated diagnostic and technical knowledge in the hands of people who previously couldn’t access it. A local mechanic might gain capabilities once available only to a manufacturer’s engineering team. Independent technicians, researchers, and small organizations could become far more capable of understanding and working with complex systems.
Yet that same mechanic could become dependent on an AI platform whose workings, access, and pricing are controlled elsewhere.
AI is also changing how knowledge itself is produced. Systems can generate software, identify patterns, and develop solutions that perform successfully even when the people using them cannot fully explain how they were produced. Evaluating an outcome is not necessarily the same as understanding the process that created it.
This raises another question about how expertise develops. As AI takes on more of the work of diagnosing, designing, and producing solutions, how will people gain the experience necessary to question those results, recognize unexpected failures, and intervene?
The question is not simply whether AI makes people more capable. It is who controls that capability, how understanding develops, and under what conditions that capability remains available.
Rethinking Independence
The mechanics and innovators I observed in the Philippines were not independent of everyone else. They relied on parts suppliers, shared knowledge, other skilled workers, customers, and networks of practical experience. Their ability to improvise and adapt came partly from those relationships, not from operating outside them.
Independence has never meant knowing or doing everything ourselves. As systems become more interconnected, our ability to act may depend less on what we can do alone and more on whether we have the knowledge, access, and authority to respond when circumstances change.
Our growing interdependence does not necessarily mean we must surrender independence. But it does mean we need to reconsider what independence, understanding, and control mean in a world where capability increasingly depends on relationships we do not fully see.
The challenge ahead is not simply to develop more advanced technologies or make existing systems more transparent. It is to recognize the changing distribution of knowledge and power, understand how these changes interact, and consider whether the relationships we are creating strengthen our capacity to respond to change or leave us increasingly dependent on others to act.
If the future depends less on what any one of us knows and more on the relationships through which knowledge, capability, and authority are distributed, how will we ensure those relationships strengthen rather than diminish our capacity to act?




